Plato vs aristotles ideas on poets essay
In fact, Classical and modern western drama can engage and learn many elements of African drama.
Here Plato shows a preference for straight narrative, in that by simply narrating events the poet may avoid entirely the explicit imitation of those characters he is speaking of, and the actors, too, can avoid placing themselves in a situation where they would imitate the evil acts of evil characters as they would perhaps not normally do.
Plato believed that Art in the form of poetry was useless, potentially dangerous to a society, psychologically destabilizing, pleases the senses and not the intellect, a misguided illusion of reality and immoral.
Harmonious, well-compositioned paintings have this same effect. Knowledge however is located within the various crafts shipbuilding, generalship etc.
Epistemology plato vs aristotle
What he means by this is that an art creation is an imitation of something physical, which in itself is an imitation of a form. In one way, the effect results from actively reading while the other way, the effect results from passive observation but all of them stimulate our emotions and minds hence attain different conceptions of morality and ethics in the society. Which is not to say that Aristotle did not turn the full force of his analytical mind upon the subject, merely that his observations on poetry are consonant with his over-all theory of Becoming. In the scope of critical literary studies, Plato and Aristotle, present arguments that question how reality is represented by Artists and the effect that Art has on society. He also agrees the most important human arts, such as music, painting, sculpture, literature, etc. It should ever be confused with the function of ethics which is simply to teach morality. Hence, according to Aristotle good Art is not useless, it is natural, educational and teaches truth. Thus, Aristotle created this break or separation between philosophical and aesthetic works. The cause of the detrimental consequences is due to weakened control of emotions of which the children are more susceptible because they are emotionally and mentally immature. Both were great segregation leaders that brought great change to the country. Butcher, S. Aristotles Poetics can be read as a response to Platos attack on art. Aristotle believed good Art is not useless, it is natural, educational, teaches truth and stimulates the political and psychological intellect of a society. He agrees that art is a kind of techne, and that there is a measure and means appropriate to the exercise of techne. These skills and history on philosophy was then past down to Aristotle.
Finnegan, Ruth. He believes this can have moral consequences.
Plato vs aristotle theory of knowledge
Art imitates idea and so it is imitation of reality. Therefore, Plato considered artists to be dangerous in the human Nature Vs. Plato and Aristotle critique poetry and the effect it has on poets and their audiences and society. He writes poetical imitations are ruinous to the understanding of the hearers, and the knowledge of their true nature is the only antidote to them. Aristotle began to favor Materialism over Plato's Idealism, and opened To what extent,how and why Plato's and Aristotle's democracy differ from the modern conception of the democracy words - 7 pages Reflection PaperManjieva EditaTo what extent, how and why, Plato and Aristotle's conception of democracy differ from the modern conception of democracy. Introduction Mimesis, as a controversial concept starting from the 15th century, is among the oldest terms in literature and artistic theory, and is certainly among the most fundamental. Clearly Aristotle is conceiving imitation as a different process from Plato. New York: Dover Publications, DuBois focused on the exact opposite of Washington. Poetics, IV, p Could we see what they see? However, it is Socrates who had the greatest influence as a teacher and mentor to Plato, evident not only in many of the doctrines and arguments we find in Plato's dialogues, but perhaps most obviously in Plato's choice of Socrates as the main character in most of his works.
It follows from this that the poet has it within his power to imitate real or imagined events; as S. The Poetics. How is it being imitated, is the imitation a straight copy, a distortion or an improvement in some way?
The charioteer, the physician, and the general are given as examples of people who have an intimate knowledge of their craft because they are aware of the uses to which it will be put.
The argument is based largely on the theory of Forms and certain relations between the art of poetry and painting.
based on 118 review